Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 15, 1869 (Tarbell v. Bowman)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1869

Colt, J.

The facts upon which the plaintiffs’ title to relief depends are sufficiently plain, as they finally appear upon the bill, answer and agreed statements, both original and supplemental. The defendants, as assignees in insolvency, were interested in certain real estate in Boston, with other parties, including the plaintiff John P. Tarbell, who was seised in fee and as tenant in common, as trustee of his wife, the other plaintiff, in part thereof. In order to secure a sale of the property to the best advantage for the estate of the insolvent, the defendants obtained the consent of all the other parties interested, that the entire property should be sold at auction in lots, and, as inducement to them for joining in the sale, it was agreed, in advance, that they should receive certain fixed amounts, at all events, out of the proceeds. The sale was at the instigation and for the benefit of the assignees. The other parties were under no necessity to sell, and the net results, after paying them according to agreement, were received by the assignees to their own use. If, therefore, under a mistake, there has been an overpayment by a purchaser at the sale, the defendants are the parties who have received the money, and should, under ordinary circumstances, be held responsible for it. From the nature of the transaction, the overpayment increases the surplus which goes to them, after settlement with the other interested parties. And'we see no reason for joining any one with them as necessary and proper parties in this suit, on the ground that they were directly or indirectly the recipients of the money so paid.

The sale at auction of the premises, by lots, took place Maj 26, 1859. The plaintiff Mrs. Tarbell became the purchaser of *343lot No. 2, and Dexter D. Bowman of the adjoining lot on the west.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.