Supreme Court of Louisiana September 15, 1869, No. 638 (State v. Hoffpauer)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1869

Taliaferro, J.

The defendant in this case was indicted for assault and battery, found guilty and sentenced to pay a fine of five hundred dollars, or in default thereof to be imprisoned three months in the parish jail.

Previous to the trial the defendant by his counsel moved to quash the indictment on the ground that the grand jury which presented the indictment was not a legally constituted body for the reason that it was drawn from a venire that had been formed under a law which was repealed and not in force at the time the grand jury was drawn.

The motion to quash was overruled by the judge a quo, who assigned as ground for his action that the venire having been drawn before the law changing the manner of drawing juries inthe'parish of Vermilion was approved or took effect, it was properly drawn. That the objection, if a good one, came too late, as it should have been by challenge, to the. array on the first day of the term. The appeal comes up on a hill of exceptions taken by the defendant to the ruling of the court.

The facts appear to be that the venire in question was drawn on the seventh day of March, 1866, under the act of 1855, which provides that the venire of forty-eight jurors to he drawn for an ensuing term of court shall be drawn from ballots taken from a list of all the qualified voters not exempt, of the parish. Revised Statutes, p. 294, sec. 3.

On the eighth day of March, 1866, the day after the drawing of the venire as above stated, an act of tbe Legislature was approved providing that in the parish of Vermilion the forty-eight jurors to be drawn prior to each term of the District Court shall be drawn from ballots taken from the names of only one hundred and fifty qualified *610voters of the parish not exempted by law. This act repealed all former laws on the same subject matter, and took effect from the date of its passage. Acts of 1866, p. 114.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.