Supreme Court of the United States January 18, 1869 (Girard v. Philadelphia)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-01-1869

Mr. Justice GRIER

delivered the opinion of the court, arid after observing th'at the attempt to restrain the alienation of the realty, being inoperative, could not affect the validity oí 'the devise, and that the income of the whole residuary was deyoted’to the three objects stated by the testator, the college being the “primary object,” and that so long as any portion of this residuary fund should be found necessary for v

its

improvement and maintenance,” on the plan and to the extent.declared in the will, the second and third objects could claim nothing — proceeded as follows:

The bill admits this to be a valid charity, and claims only the residue after that is satisfied. Now, it is admitted (for it has been so decided),

†

that till February,. 1854, the corporation was vested with a complete title to the whole residue of the estate of Stephen Girard, subject to these charitable trusts, and consequently, at that date, his heirs at law had nri right, title, or interest whatsoever in the same. But the bill alleges that the act of the legislature of that date (commonly called the “Consolidation Act”), which purports to be a supplement to the -original act incorporating the city, has either dissolved or destroyed the. identity of the original corporation, and it is consequently unable any longer to administer the trust. Now, if this were true, the only

*13

. consequence would be, not that the charities or trust should fail, but that the chancellor should substitute another trustee.

It .is not insisted that the mere change or abbreviation of the name has destroyed the identity of the corporation. The bill even admits that a small addition to its territory and jurisdiction,might not have that effect, but 'that the annexation of twenty-nine boroughs and townships has smothered it to death, or rendered it utterly incapable of administering trusts or charities committed to it when its boundaries were Vine and South Streets, and the two rivers.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.