Supreme Court of the United States February 18, 1869 (Thomson v. Dean)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-1869

The CHIEF JUSTICE

delivered the opinion of the court.

The question is whether the decree in this case was final for the purpose of appeal?

The eighth rule of the court, prescribing the practice of the United States courts in equity, directs that “if the decree be for the performance of any specific act, it shall prescribe the time within which the act shall be done, of'which the defendant is bound to take notice,” and that, “on affidavit by the plaintiff of non-performance within the prescribed time, the clerk shall issue a writ of attachment against the • delinquent party, from which he shall not be discharged

*345

unless on full compliance, or by special order'enlarging the time.”

In- this case the decree directs the performance of a specific act, and requires that, it be done forthwith. The effect of the act when done is to invest the transferees with all the •rights of ownership. It changes the property in the stock as absolutely and as completely as could be done by execution on a decree for sale. It looks to no future modification or change of the decf-ee. No such change or modification was possible after the term, except on rehearing or by bill of review in the Circuit Court, or through appeal in this court.

So far as the court below was concerned, the decree in the case determined the principal matter in controversy between . the parties. And since the decree could not be changed except through a new and distinct proceeding, it determined that matter finally.

Why, then, must it not be regarded as a final decree within the meaning of the acts of Congress providing for appeals ?

. 1 The eighth rule of practice to which we have' referred certainly regards such a decree as that now.uñder consideration as final in respect to the act to be performed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.