Tennessee Supreme Court September 15, 1870 (Huddleston v. Williams)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-09-1870
Turney, J.,
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The bill in this case is demurred to, upon the ground that complainants have a plain, adequate, unembarrassed remedy at law. The demurrer is allowed by this Court.
The bill charges, substantially, that some time in 1861, John Á. "Williams left the State, went to Kentucky, and joined the Federal Army; that when he left he was indebted to some of complainants, who filed an attachment bill, attaching certain personal property. Their attachment suit matured, and the property was sold under a decree of the Chancery Court. At the sale, some of the complainants purchased of the property, and others were present, but did not purchase; others were not present; that "Williams, on the 3rd day of February, 1866, commenced an action in the Circuit Court of Union county, to recover of them the value of the personal property sold, in pursuance of said decree, by the Clerk and Master, whose personal representative is sued at law, and who is also complainant in the bill.
The prayer of the bill is, to enjoin the suit at law, &c. According to the statements of the bill, the fact of the purchase at a Chancery sale must be, of course, shown by the proof of the plaintiff at law. But if this were not so, under a proper state of pleading, that sale and purchase can be shown at law, and when shown, will acquit complainants who purchased, of liability to the action of "Williams. Those who were not present, or who did not purchase, are acquitted under the general issue. From the statements in the bill, we are unable to see any difficulty to complainants in making the *581defense at law, as the general issue raises every question of defense, and admits all the necessary evidence to sustain it.
It is insisted by complainants, that theirs is a bill to execute a decree. We do not think so.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit