Supreme Court of the United States April 18, 1870 (Michigan Bank v. Eldred)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-04-1870

Mr. Justice CLIFFORD

stated the case, and delivered the - opinion of the court.

Promissory notes, given for the payment of money, without any condition or contingency, and payable to order or bearer, are as much commercial instruments as bills of exchange, and the title to the same, and their transfer from

*547

one person to another, are governed and regulated by the same rules of commercial law.

Authorities may be found where it is held that it is not essential to the character of a promissory note or bill of exchange that it should be negotiable, and that other words besides the words “or order,” or the words “or bearer,” may be employed to express the quality of negotiability; but it is not necessary to discuss those topics, as the inquiry before the court has respect to the execution, transfer, and title of a negotiable promissory note in the ordinary form.

*

Examined carefully, the pleadings and evidence exhibit the following facts, which are material to the present investigation : Claiming title to the note in question, the plaintiffs instituted the present suit against the defendant and oneTJri Baleom and Elisha Eldred, alleging that they were copartners in trade under the firm name of Eldreds & Baleom. They, the defendants, were engaged in business both in Chicago and Milwaukee, and the record shows that they were sued as indorsers of the note described in the declaration. Only one of their number, to wit, the defendant, resided in that State, and he only was served with process. Besides a special count against the defendants as’the indorsers of the note, the declaration also contained the common counts, to which was annexed a copy of the note, as notice that the note would be offered in evidence under those counts. Process having been served, the present defendant appeared, and pleaded the general issue, and the parties went to trial, and the verdict and judgment were for the defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.