New York Court of Appeals February 21, 1871 (Coleman v. . Eyre)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-1871

Rapallo, J.

The plaintiff was interested to the extent of one-fourth in the profits or losses of a shipment of coffee undertaken by him jointly with other parties. After the adventure had been begun, and before the coffee had reached its port of destination, it was mutually agreed between the plaintiff and the defendant that the latter should have one-half interest in the plaintiff’s one-fourth interest in the adventure. The speculation resulted in a loss, and this action was brought to recover one-half of the plaintiff’s proportion of such loss. It is now claimed on the part of the defendant that no valid contract was made between him and the plaintiff; that inasmuch as the plaintiff had embarked in the speculation before and without reference to any arrangement with the defendant, and the defendant had not done or contributed anything to aid in the joint enterprise, there was no partnership, and no consideration for the undertaking of the plaintiff to give him one-half of the profits; that therefore the defendant could not have enforced payment of half the profits, if the adventure had been successful, and consequently no agreement on his part to contribute to the loss can be implied.

This argument assumes that the agreement was simply that the defendant should have one-lialf of the profits, which the plaintiff might make out of the adventure, in case it should

*41

prove successful. But such was not the agreement proved. The agreement was that the defendant should share with the plaintiff in the adventure, and it seems to have been clearly understood that he should participate in the result, whether it should prove a profit or a loss. That it might result in a loss was contemplated by the parties.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.