Supreme Judicial Court of Maine July 1, 1871 (Cary v. Herrin)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-07-1871
Dickerson, J.
The plaintiffs bring this bill as heirs of the late Shepard Carv, deceased, to redeem a mortgate given by him to the defendant. The case was committed to a master whose report was presented for acceptance at the February term of the supreme judicial court for the county of Aroostook, a. d. 1871. The plaintiffs made a motion to set aside the report and have it recommitted, but the presiding justice overruled the motion, proforma, and ordered the report to be accepted, and the plaintiffs excepted.
The principal question reserved is, whether the master properly allowed the defendant to testify to facts that transpired prior to the death of the plaintiffs’ ancestor, against their objection.
The correctness of this ruling is attempted to be maintained on two grounds:
I. Because if is in accordance with the rules of evidence in equity proceedings. The rules of evidence are, in general, the same in equity as they are at law, both as to the competency of witnesses and other evidence. It is true, that when the parties to a bill in equity are merely nominal or fiduciary, or the facts depend solely upon the knowledge of the parties, and oath is so balanced against oath that it becomes necessary to determine the degree of credit to bo giren to the parties, it is competent to examine both parties, not as witnesses for themselves or each other, but to enlighten the conscience of the court. In other cases, too, parties may be examined by mutual consent, under the discretion of the court. But it is never competent for a master in chancery to examine a party against the objection of the adverse party, when, from the position of the parties, such examination would give that party an undue advantage over the other. 3 Greenl. Ev. § 838.
The plaintiff’s are parties in interest, and might be greatly prejudiced by the testimony of the defendant, not only as to facts that took place prior to the death of their ancestor, but which, also, were peculiarly within his knowledge.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit