Tennessee Supreme Court June 7, 1871 (McCaleb v. Crichfield)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-06-1871

Feeeman, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The bill is filed by the complainants to recover their interest under the will of Henry Crichfield, Sr., of the said Richard and William, and of E. N. Cun-nigham as grand-children of said Henry Crichfield, Sr., and by McCaleb, to recover an interest as assignee of Johnathan McKinney, and wife Martha, said Martha being a grand-daughter of testator. The said Martha died before her husband Johnathan McKinney, the husband not long after, and they left two children, Joseph and Samuel McKinney, infants, their only heirs and distributees.

The interests sought to be recovered are claimed under fifth and sixth clauses of the will of Henry Crichfield, Sr., which provides, that all the remainder of my estate, including land and personal property, shall be sold by my executors, and proceeds equally divided between all my grand-children, and also William Ball, a son of a grand-daughter. The sixth clause provides, that if any of my grand-children should die after my death, the share going to such grand-child shall be equally divided between his or her brothers and sisters, provided the deceased had not received his share before his death.

It is alleged that there were “ thirty-five grandchildren at death of testator, in 1858, and that the legatees were so numerous at death of testator, and *290have since so changed by marriage, death, etc., and scattered by lapse of time and disturbances through which the country has passed, that it is inconvenient, expensive, and in fact wholly impracticable to make them all parties by name.” This is the allegation in original bill, and the same excuse is substantially given in an amended bill filed in the case. A demurrer was filed to the original bill by defendants: first, because it appears by the bill that Henry Crichfield, Sr., left other heirs besides those named as complainants not made parties to the bill; and second, for want of equity in face of bill.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.