Supreme Court of Vermont February 15, 1872 (Wilkinson v. Wait)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-02-1872

*513The opinion of the court was delivered by

Peck, J.

The jury have found that the pair of oxen in question were the only oxen the plaintiff owned, unless the oxen in Lincoln’s possession at the time the defendant attached the oxen in question, were also the property of the plaintiff within the meaning of the statute exempting one pair of oxen from attachment. The jury having also found-that the oxen in Lincoln’s possession were there under a contract of sale for $240 by plaintiff to Lincoln, with a stipulation that they were to remain the plaintiff’s property till “ paid for,” the court was right in holding that the pair of oxen attached by the defendant, which were the absolute property of the plaintiff and in his possession, were exempt from attachment, notwithstanding the plaintiff’s interest as such conditional vendor in the oxen sold to Lincoln.

The oxen in question being exempt from attachment by our State law, the property in them did not pass to the asignee of the plaintiff in bankruptcy, nor the title of the plaintiff become impaired or affected by the bankrupt act, but is saved from its operation by express provision to that effect. From this it follows that the assignee had no right to take the oxen ; and the defendant - was not bound to deliver them to the assignee, and cannot protect himself from this action, nor mitigate the damages, by showing such delivery even under protest, on demand of the assignee; It is claimed on the part of the defense that the United States district court had jurisdiction of the question as to the exemption of this property from attachment, and consequently from the oper-' ation of the bankrupt law, and that the plaintiff’s only remedy is by application to the district court, at least except for .nominal damages for taking and detaining the oxen up to the time the as-signee took them from defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.