Tennessee Supreme Court January 31, 1872 (Bittick v. Wilkins)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-01-1872

Deaderioe:, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The complainants as sureties of H. Hill, Sheriff of Williamson county, paid a large sum of money to B. B,. Hughes, who had obtained judgment against defendant Wilkins and others, upon which execution was issued, which came to the hands of the Sheriff. The Sheriff failed to make due return, and judgment upon motion was rendered against him and his sureties, upon which execution issued; and having paid the judgment, complainants filed their injunction and attachment bill in the Chancery Court at Franklin, seeking to have a debt due from the county of Williamson to defendant Wilkins, of about $600, applied towards the satisfaction of the amount paid by them on his debt to Hughes.

Complainants claim that, as sureties of the Sheriff, having paid Wilkins’s debt to Hughes, they have an equity to be substituted to the rights' of Hughes against Wilkins. The complainant Bittick died pending the suit, and it was revived in the names of Jo. J. Green and Jas. T. Shannon, his executors.

The claim for indemnity on the part of the surety against the principal is not founded upon contract, but upon a principle of natural equity and justice. It is the creature of equity, and the practice of sub-rogation or substitution, or the cession of remedies, is so administered as to secure essential justice without regard to form. 1 L. C. Eq., 86-7.

*309Payment by one who stands in the relation of a surety, while it may extinguish the remedy, or discharge the security as respects the creditor, has not that effect as between the principal debtor and the surety. As to the surety, it operates as an assignment in equity of the debt and all legal proceedings upon it; and in favor of the surety, the debt and all its obligations and incidents are considered as still subsisting. lb., 88.

Our own decisions have somewhat modified this doctrine. In 4 Hum.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.