Tennessee Supreme Court September 15, 1872 (Carmichael v. White)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1872

Nicholson, C. J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

This was a suit in the Circuit Court of Hawkins county, on a note for $1,375.50, dated March 15, 1862, and payable six months after date. Upon the trial of the cause, on the plea of nil debit, the defendant offered to testify that the said note was executed in consideration of stock purchased- at inflated Confederate money prices; that although the' note is drawn payable in- dollars, the contract in fact was, that the note should be paid in Confederate money or treasury notes, and that said notes were depreciated — but the evidence was excluded by the court. The jury, under the ruling of the Circuit Judge, found for the plaintiff, giving him a verdict for the face of the note, with interest. The defendants have appealed in error.

It is .insisted for defendants that the court below erred in excluding the evidence offered as to the consideration of the note and as to the contract for its *266payment in Confederate money. It is conceded for plaintiff, that under the authority of Thorington v. Smith, it would be competent to show by parol evidence, from the surrounding circumstances, in what sense the word “ dollars ” was used by the parties to the note. But it is denied that it would be competent to prove directly by parol that the parties used the word “dollar” as meaning Confederate money, in pursuance of a contract. To allow such evidence, it is said, would violate the well established rule, which prohibits the resort to parol testimony to alter’ or change a written contract. But this is assuming that the parties used the word dollars in the note in its technical sense, as meaning gold or silver dollars or their equivalents. That such was not their meaning, it is conceded, may be shown by parol proof, by showing the surrounding circumstances, from which it may be implied that the parties contracted with reference to “dollars,” as represented by Confederate notes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.