Mississippi Supreme Court July 1, 1872 (Shines v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-07-1872

Jeffords, J.:

The plaintiff in error, Shines, was indicted before the circuit court of Madison county, in this state, for the crime of grand larceny, was tried at the September term, 1867, of that court, and a verdict rendered against him of “ guilty as charged in the’ indictment.”

There are three assignments of error, but as the third assignment must be decisive of this case, we pass over the others, and proceed to examine this alone, which is, that “ the court erred in the sentence passed on appellant, the same not being in accordance with the indictment and verdict of the jury.”

The indictment alleged the value of the property stolen to be thirty dollars.

The proof, as embodied in the bill of exceptions, discloses the fact that Shines stole a yearling calf of the value of from five to seven dollars, which, under our statute, is petit larceny.

On the 7th day of October, 1867, the jury returned a verdict of “ guilty as charged in the indictment,” without finding the value of the property alleged to have been stolen, and without specifying the grade of the offense. On the following day the defendant moved the court to set aside the verdict of the jury; which motion having been heard and considered, was overruled by the court. The same day the court “ ordered that a verdict of guilty of petit larceny be entered upon the minutes,” and thereupon sentenced the defendant to pay a fine of twenty-five dollars and the costs of prosecution, and to remain in the custody of the sheriff until the fine and costs should be paid.

There is, of course, no question whatever but that the indictment charging grand larceny embraced also the charge of petit larceny; and there is no doubt that if the testimony would not justify a conviction of the greater, the jury might have returned a verdict of guilty of the lesser offense.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.