U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern New York January 27, 1872 (Sawyer v. Bixby)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-01-1872

WOODRUFF, Circuit Judge.

The complainant alleges that the defendants have infringed re-issued letters patent granted to him October 1st, 1867, for an “improvement in putting up powders, &c.” The claim contained in the specification annexed is in these words: “What I claim as a new article of manufacture is, a package or case, which, when made with distributing holes and filled, is cemented by the wax or wafer, as set forth.”

The specification and the specimens of the manufacture produced show, that what the plaintiff claims as an invention, is a small cylindrical box, perforated at the end after the manner of a pepper or sand box, for the purpose of conveniently and evenly distributing the powder contained within it, when put to use, and the closing of these perforations by wax, or wafer, or paper, pasted, or made to adhere by mucilage, or some glutinous substance, for retaining the powder when sold and transported by the manufacturer, dealer or customer, the wax or wafer being removed, or the paper punctured, when it is desired to use the powder. I am decidedly of opinion, that, in this device, there is no patentable invention. Pepper boxes, sand boxes, dredge boxes, and spice boxes, either of which is exactly adapted to the distribution of powder of any kind, are not new and are not claimed to be new. In construction and effect, they are substantially like, and, in mechanical structure, identical with, the plaintiff’s cylindrical box, perforated at one end for the distribution of the powder. In respect of distribution, the plaintiff employs no new means and produces no new result. The closing of packages of various forms, and of bottles, by wax. or wafer, or the pasting of paper, made to *562attach itself by the use of gum, or other adhesive material, is no more new than the other; and, when those or either of them are applied to the openings in the plaintiff’s boxes, they produce no new result They close the openings, and that is all.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.