Court of Appeals of Tennessee April 15, 1873 (Dismukes v. Dismukes)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1873
The Chancellor :
This is a petition for divorce upon the ground of wilful and malicious desertion for two whole years, and also because “ on the — day of —, 1872 and ’73 the defendant committed adultery in said county with one Andrew Harris, and divers other persons to petitioner unknown, as petitioner is informed and believes, and he charges that she is now simply a common prostitute.”
The proof not only fails to make out a case of wilful and malicious desertion, on the part of the defendant, but does clearly establish that he deserted her, though perhaps not without cause. Of course, the application fails on this ground.
I have recently held in Horne v. Horne (ante, p. 259), that under § 2452 of the Code, and the decisions of the supreme court, the cause of divorce relied on must be “ set forth particularly and specially,” with all “ the circumstances of time and place, with reasonable certainty.” The petitioner is not compelled to rely upon any one charge, but may set forth any number of them, identifying each of them by such particularities of time, place and person as will enable the defendant to prepare to meet the charge. Nor do these requirements demand mathematical exactness. All that the law requires is, “reasonable certainty.” In this view, I granted the *267divorce in Horne v. Horne, although the place of the adultery charged was not distinctly located, and the time somewhat vaguely limited by the words “recently and repeatedly.” In that case, I went to the verge of the law because two of the requisites of the circumstances were set forth with “ reasonable certainty,” and all of them were distinctly made by the proof. I am here asked to go a step further, and because the person is designated to dispense with the specifications of “ time and place.” For the place, according to this petition, is anywhere in Davidson county, and the time is any hour of two years, 1872 and 1873.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit