New York Court of Appeals December 15, 1874 (Boyd v. Schlesinger)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1874
Grover, J.
The defendant, in his answer, set up counterclaims for the specific performance of the contract, which the plaintiff sought, by the action, to have adjudged vacated and void, as to the three lots to be conveyed'by the plaintiff to the defendant, with a deduction from the contract-price of the value of the leasehold interest in lot sixty, and, in ease of the inability of the plaintiff to give a good title to the three lots, for damages for non-performance of the contract. These claims he had a right to set up in his answer, and have tried and determined in the action. (Code, § 150.)
The Special Term awarded a specific performance of the contract as to the three lots, with an abatement from the contract-price of the value of the leasehold interest to be transferred in lot sixty, having found, as a fact, that the plaintiff could not give a good title to the latter. Upon appeal from the judgment, the General Term modified it, by awarding specific performance of the entire contract by the plaintiff, in case the defendant consented to take the assignment of the *306judgment, and, upon his consent thereto, affirmed the judgment. From this judgment the plaintiff appeals to this court. The first question to be determined, as the plaintiff appeals from the entire judgment, is, whether the General Term was right, without the consent of the plaintiff, in adjudging a specific performance as to the leasehold interest, although the defendant assented to such modification. The case shows that the' plaintiff, in September, 1866, the time for the completion of the contract, offered a conveyance of the three lots, which- he was to convey in fee, as to which there was no objection as to his title, and also to assign the corporation leases of lot sixty, pursuant to the contract, and demanded payment of the contract-price.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit