Supreme Court of Alabama June 15, 1874 (Bozeman v. Rose's Executors)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1874
B. F. SAFFOLD, J.
The issue made by the parties is simply the measure of damages for the breach of the contract by the complainant in not delivering the cotton at the time *324appointed. The mortgage recites that, on default of the obligors in delivering the cotton, the mortgagee may sell the premises, and “ after paying off said obligation, and the expenses of such sale,” shall return any surplus to the-mortgagor. It was proved that the complainant had about sixty bales, or somewhat more than one half, of the cotton on the 1st of January, 1865, which he retained until August, 1865, and might, at any time during the interval, have delivered acceptably to Rose. He did not deliver any, but sold what he had for about thirty cents per pound in August. The proof tended to show that cotton was worth in Wetumpka, on the 1st of January, 1865, about two and a half cents per pound in gold. But the manner of arriving at this valuation was to estimate the value of each in Confederate money. The chancellor decreed, that the complainant should pay the value of the sixty bales at the date of his sale, which, by agreement, was fixed at thirty cents per pound. He was charged for the remainder three cents a pound, its price in United States currency by comparison with Confederate money, on the day it should have been delivered. The appellant insists that the latter rule is the measure of his accountability for the sixty bales.
It seems inequitable that a debtor should enjoy the profit gained by his deliberate breach of contract, with the means of partial compliance, at least, in his hands, when his creditor is willing to accept such performance as he can make. But even equity must be governed by rules of larger uniyersality than application to a single case.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit