Indiana Supreme Court November 15, 1874 (Shane v. Lowry)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1874

Downey, J.

Suit by the appellee against the appellants,, on a promissory note made by the appellants to Londheimer, "Weiskopf & Co., payable in bank, and assigned by the payees-to the appellee.

The complaint is in two paragraphs. Each alleges an assignment of the note, and not an indorsement. In alleging the assignment, the statement is, that the payees, by their firm name, made the assignment. Each paragraph alleges a protest of the note for non-payment, and the protest is made part of the complaint. This was unnecessary. Neither protest nor notice of non-payment is necessary in such case. The maker ought to know whether he has paid the note or not, without any notice from other parties.

The defendants demurred to each of the paragraphs of the complaint, on the ground that it did not state facts sufficient to-constitute a cause of action. The demurrers were overruled.

*206An answer consisting of seven paragraphs was filed.

The plaintiff demurred to all the paragraphs, except the first, and the demurrers were all overruled, except that to the seventh paragraph, which was sustained.

Reply in denial of the paragraphs held good.

Trial by the court; finding for the plaintiff; motion for a new trial overruled; and judgment for the plaihtiff.

The assignments of error are:

1. Overruling the demurrer of the defendants to the complaint.

2. Sustaining the demurrer to the seventh paragraph of the answer.

’ 3. Error in the conclusions of law by the court.

4. Overruling the motion for a new trial.

We do not discover any defect in the complaint, in either paragraph, for which the demurrer should have been sustained. It is claimed by counsel for the appellants, that the paragraphs of the complaint are bad, because the proper names of the payees are not stated, but only the firm name. We do not think this a good objection under the demurrer. Budd v. Wilkinson, 5 Blackf. 264. There are other cases to the same •effect.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.