Supreme Court of Iowa October 26, 1874 (Carroll v. McCoy)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-10-1874
Beck, J.
The consideration of the objections made by defendant to the instructions will cover all points made in the argument of counsel.
I. The jury were directed that if the plaintiff topk the child at defendant’s request, the law will imply a promise on 1. costbact: . cS?ici.?lfc °f her part to pay for its support. To this defendant objects on the ground that defendant would not be liable if there was an understanding that the child should be taken care of without charge. This is true but, in the absence of proof of such an understanding, upon request of defendant for the services, the law implies, liability on the part of defendant. A subsequent instruction directs the jury that if they found such an understanding or agreement, defendant is not liable.
II. Another instruction directed the jury that, if they found it was agreed between the parties that the charge for keeping 2.-: stat-irte oí limita- ' tions. the child should run from year to year, no recovery . . . „ . ,. , „ can be had tor any period beyond five years prior to the commencement of the suit. And still another was to the effect that if the child was taken at the request' of defendant, and nothing was said in regard to the time plaintiff was to keep him, and defendant immediately left the country where she resided, and plaintiff and the child remained until about two years before suit was brought, and came to the United *40States, the contract was entire and would contiue until such time as it should be terminated by the mother taking the custody of the child, or until he arrived of age. .To the last instruction objection is urged.
The instruction contemplates the case of a contract to run for an indefinite time, and to be terminated by the act of defendant or the majority of the boy. Such a contract would be implied by the facts upon which the instruction is based.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit