The Superior Court of New York City January 31, 1874 (Blewett v. Baker)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-01-1874

Br the Court.—Curtis, J.

Nearly all the questions in this case rest upon the facts that were fully and impartially considered and determined correctly on the trial. The action was brought to recover damages for the breach of a contract. The proofs on the part of the plaintiff, and the pleadings showed that he contracted verbally with the defendant to manufacture 'fifteen thousand of “Baker’s Patent Bolster Spring Bed,” at twenty cents each, the defendant to furnish the materials and the use of the machinery. The contract between the parties, as first made, provided that the plaintiff should procure a lease of the premises where the work was to be performed, and find security for the rent, and assign the lease to the defendant. The plaintiff procured the lease, found security, and handed it to the defendant, about the middle of April, 1872, who after retaining it two or three days, objected to the clause for renewal, and thereupon a modification was made of the contract, by which the price of the work was reduced to twenty cents a bed, and the defendant was to pay the rent of the premises. The reduction in the price to be paid on fifteen thousand beds, amounts to one hundred dollars less than the rent to be paid for the first year. The plaintiff procured a new lease, in accordance with the agreement between the parties at the time of the modification of the contract.

*25On April 24 following, the plaintiff notified the defendant that this new lease was perfected and ready for his acceptance, and requested him to appoint a„ place where it could be accepted or transferred to him; but he refused, saying it was too late, and that he hired another place, raising no other objection. There was testimony on the part of the defendant that this lease was to have been in his name, and that he objected to receiving it also on that ground. There was a verdict for the plaintiff for seven hundred and fifty dollars!

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.