The Superior Court of New York City December 9, 1874 (Burke v. Wolfe)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-12-1874
By the Court.—Freedman, J.
Upon the trial, the defense of a satisfaction and discharge of the indebtedness sued upon, by Udolpho Wolfe, in his lifetime, was wholly abandoned; for the defendant gave no evidence tending to establish it.
As to the further defense of a satisfaction and discharge of such indebtedness by the plaintiffs, in consideration of the stay of, and the rendition of services by the defendant, in the business to be continued by them, as executors, pursuant to the directions of the testator, there was a clear conflict of testimony, and the question depended entirely upon the relative credibility of the parties. An examination of the whole evidence fails to disclose a tangible ground on which the determination of this branch of the case, which the referee has made, can be disturbed.
The referee allowed to the defendant the sum of sixty dollars, paid by Udolpho Wolfe to Mrs. Lizzie Garland, and erroneously deducted from the amount of commissions earned by the defendant, as claimed in the answer, and also the sum of fifty dollars, received by Nettie Wolfe, as to which the defendant had raised no dispute whatever.
The sum of four hundred and forty-one dollars, being the aggregate amount of sundry bills which the defendant owed to third parties, and which Udolpho Wolfe paid to them for defendant’s account, constituted, under the evidence, which the referee must be deemed to have credited, a proper charge against the defendant.
The claim advanced by the defendant, that Udolpho *267Wolfe had promised and agreed to contribute, and, in fact, had contributed toward the support of defendant’s mother, was not disputed ; but the evidence was conflicting as to the extent to which Udolpho Wolfe had thus obligated himself.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit