Supreme Court of the United States January 18, 1874 (Shrewsbury v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-01-1874
Mr. Justice HUNT
delivered thb opinion of the court.
It can- hardly be denied.by the most zealous advocate that the two contracts before us differ essentially in their nature and form. The contract made with the claimant is a contract for the transportation of corn, at a price fixed, and in quantity not to exceed 15,000,000 pounds. The sole duty
*668
of the claimant under this contract was to carry and deliver the corn. He did not purchase it nor own it; he had nothing to do with its value or quality, and could neither make nor lose by a fluctuation in .the value of the corn.
The. later contract with Fuller & Tiernan, on. the other hand, is strictly a contract for the purchase of 18,000 bushels of corn, to be delivered at a place and within a time named, and at a price specified, to be paid on the delivery and acceptance of the corn.1 In this case the corn is the property of Fuller & Tiernan until delivered. They purchase it; they own it. If the price of corn in the market varies essentially they will make a. profit or be losers, according' as the direction of the variation shall be. Their contract is to furnish the corn at Fort Union, New Mexico, and they are at liberty to obtain it from any source they choose. They have no claim-for payment until delivery, and the United States have no ownership of the corn until delivery and paymeut.
The foundation, however, of the claimant’s demand rests upon the identity of these dissimilar contracts. Having contracted to deliver to him for transportation all the corn of which the quartermaster’s department required transportation from. Fort Leavenworth to Fort Union, he insists that this contract is .violated by a purchase by the subsistence department of the United States, made at Fort Leavenworth, of corn to be delivered by the seller of the same at Fort Union.' This view cannot be sustained. There is not only not an identity, but there is not a similarity between the contracts.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit