Supreme Court of the United States November 23, 1874, 51 (Hearne v. Marine Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-11-1874

Mr. Justice SWAYNE

having stated the case,.delivered

-the opinion of the court.

. The reformation of written contracts for fraud or mistake' 'is an ordinary head of equity-jurisdiction. The-rules which govern the exercise of this power are founded in good sense and.are well settled.- Where the agreement as reduced-to -writing, omits or contains térms of stipulations contrary to the common intention of the parties, the instrument will -be corrected so as to make it couform to their real intent. The parties will be placed as they would have stood if the mis-, .take had not-occurred.

*

Thé party alleging the mistake must show exactly in-what it.consists, and the correction that should be made. The evidence must be such as^to.leave no reasonable dpubt upon .the mind of the court as to éither of these points.

†

The

*491

mistake must be mutual and common to both parties to the instrument. It must appear that both havó done what neither intended.

*

A mistake on one side may ,be a ground for rescinding, but not for reforming, a contract.

†

Where the minds of the parties have not met there is no contract, and'hence none to he rectified.

‡

This jurisdiction is applied, where necessary and'proper, to the reformation of contracts of insurance.

§

Here the application was to insure on a charter “ from Liverpool to Cuba, and load for Europe,

via

Ealmouth,” &c. This was indefinite as to Cuba, and may have been regarded by the company as ambiguous. The answer'was, as “requested, we have entered $5000 on charter

to fort in Cuba, and thence to

port of advice and discharge in Europe.” This answer shows clearly two things: (1.) How the company understood the proposition. (2.) That they agreed to iusure according to that understanding, and not otherwise.

There was no mistake nor misapprehension on their part. The circumstances show there could be none. ’

The correspondence between the parties constituted a preliminary agreement. The answer to Hearne’s proposal was plain and explicit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.