The Superior Court of New York City June 15, 1875 (Mayor of New York v. New York & Staten Island Ferry Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1875

Van Vorst, J.

The learned counsel for the defendants urges that the right to establish ferries is a sovereign power, and that the legislature has the right to take away or impair a franchise granted by it.

¡No such right to recall can with any reason or justice, be urged with regard to the ferries in existence when the grant from the sovereign power was originally made, and which were clearly recognized and confirmed, with their issues and profits, in the corporation of the city of ¡New York in perpetuity. The question is now only considered, and the right to recall or revoke applied, with respect to ferries to be established after the grant.

It is claimed by the defendants’ counsel that whatever was granted by the Montgomerie charter in 1730, and the Eastin charters, known as the Dongan and Cornbury, and confirmed by the state afterward, in. regard to the right to set up and establish future ferries by the corporation of the city of ¡New York, is a political power only, unaccompanied by any interest, and may be recalled at any time by the sovereign authority before the power has been actually executed.

This view is sustained by the opinion of judge Hogeboom, at special term, in The People agt. The Mayor, &c., of New York, (32 Barb., 102).

That learned judge, in the course of his opinion, notices a distinction between a grant of actual property and a right to create property—between a conveyance of an existing ferry and a grant of a power to establish future ferries. He says: “ The one conveys property, and with it all the ordinary rights which attach to the ownership and possession of property ; the other is a mere naked power, not coupled with an interest nor conferring an interest.” The judge concedes that “ powers coupled with an interest—■ powers conferring rights of property — are incapable of recall.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.