Supreme Court of Missouri January 15, 1875 (Wilbur v. Johnson)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1875
Wagner, Judge,
delivered the opinion of the court.
The plaintiff brought her action in the court below, against the defendant, for a breach of marriage contract, and claimed $10,000 damages. On a trial of the issues framed, the jury awarded her $2,000, for which amount judgment was rendered and defendant appealed.
The evidence in reference to the contract was contradictory. Plaintiff was sworn in her own behalf, and she testified positively to the fact, that the contract of marriage was entered into between them, and that she was ready and willing to comply with it on her part, but that defendant had refused and married another woman. She was corroborated and sustained by other testimony, and the only evidence to the contrary was given by the defendant himself.
*602The verdict of the jury is conclusive on the question, and fully establishes the contract. In the course of the examination in chief, the plaintiffs counsel put to the witness direct, or leading questions, to which the defendant objected. His objections were overruled, and he excepted, and now assigns the ruling of the court for error.
■ Whilst as a general rule, leading questions are'not permissible in a direct examination, yet their admission is a matter resting very much in the sound discretion of the court, and it is too well settled to require the citation of any authority, that where they are allowed, their admissibility cannot be assigned for error, nor furnish any reason for a reversal. We cannot see that they were objectionable for any reason except that they were leading.
It seems that plaintiff was seduced by the defendant after the promise of marriage, and that a child was born in consequence.of the illicit intercourse between the parties. When the plaintiff was being examined, she was permitted to testify in reference to defendant’s demeanor towards the child, and his recognizing it as his ; and it is insisted that this was erroneous, because no contract of marriage had been proved.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit