U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Louisiana November 15, 1875 (Sala v. New Orleans)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1875

WOODS, Circuit Judge.

As the cause is now submitted for final decree, it is too late to grant that part of the prayer of the. bill which asks for a receiver to take possession and charge of the water-works until the final disposition of the case. The only other prayer is that the city may be restrained from selling, leasing or hypothecating the water-works. The theory of the complainants seems to be that the bonds issued by the city in payment for the water-works, being absolutely void for want of power in the city to issue the bonds and therefore to make the contract of sale, in which the issue of bonds formed a necessary stipulation, the sale was void and the Commercial Bank still remained the owner of the water-works; that the present holders of the city water-works bonds are subrogated to the rights and property of the bank, and the city ought to be enjoined from any act which would embarrass the title of the bondholders. In my judgment, the theory of the complainants is unsound.

The act of April 1, 1833, “to incorporate the Commercial Bank of New Orleans,” and which constitutes the charter of the bank, with all its material provisions, is a-contract between the state and the bank, the obligation of which cannot be impaired by subsequent legislation. Dartmouth College v. Woodward, 4 Wheat. [17 U. S.] 518; Providence Bank v. Billings. 4 Pet. [29 U. S.] 514; State Bank of Ohio v. Knoop, 16 How. [57 U. *224S.] 369; Dodge v. Woolsey, 18 How. [59 U. S.] 331; Jefferson Branch Bank v. Skelly, 1 Black [66 U. S.] 436; The Bingkampton Bridge, 3 Wall. [70 U. S.] 51; Allen v. McKean [Case No. 229]. As already seen, the charter provided, that at the expiration of thirty-five years, the city of New Orleans might purchase from the bank its waterworks at an appraised value, and the bank was at the time specified, and on the terms specified, in case the city elected to ptirchase, required to sell.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.