Supreme Court of the United States February 15, 1875, 180 (Burnhisel v. Firman)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-02-1875

Mr. Justice SWAYNE

delivered the opinion of the court; considering the two questions raised in the argument, in the order in which they were raised :

I. The bases of the calculation of interest made by Bnrnhisel and Wright were wrong, and the result was the aggregate amount of the two notes of April 26th, 1872, which was a sum much too large. Burnhisel was then entitled,

1st. To the face of the two original notes to him, with 25 per cent, interest upon each for one year, and the lawful rate of interest of the Territory where no rate is specified down to the date of the settlement; and,

2d. To the face of the note to Pond with the like lawful rate of interest after its maturity down to the same period.

†

The implication of the “ act relative to interest,” of February 14th, 1868, is exactly the same as the affirmation of the act upon the same subject of 1869. The latter act was, therefore, unnecessary.

‡

Both these acts fix the rate at 10 per cent, where no rate has been agreed upon. What it was in such cases, prior to the taking effect of the first act, we are not advised.

*177

For the amount due upon the two original notes to Burnhisel and upon the one to Pond, transferred to Burnhisel, the two later notes, with the rate of interest stipulated in them, and the mortgages securing them, were, aside from the objection arising under the Bankrupt law, unquestionably valid securities.

*

In Pennsylvania, where there is a statute making usury penal, but not declaring the contract void, a usurious bond and mortgage may be enforced for the amount actually due.

†

II. In order to bring a security for a debt within the provision of the Bankrupt law, relied upon by the appellee, it is necessary that all the prescribed conditions should concur.

If either element of the combination be wanting, there is no infringement of the law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.