Supreme Court of the United States December 18, 1875 (Atherton v. Fowler)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-1875

Me. Chief Justice Waite

delivered the opinion of the court.

The plaintiffs in error claimed title to the hay in controversy in this case in consequence of alleged rights acquired under the act of Congress, passed March .3, 1863, entitled “ An act to grant the right of pre-emption to certain purchasers on the ‘ Soscol Ranch,’ in the State of California.” 12 Stat. 808. The decision of the State court was against their title. This presents a question within the jurisdiction of this court.

*146

The'judgment

of

the Supreme

Court is the final judgment in the suit, within, the meaning of the act of Congress. Rev. Stat. 709. It reversed and modified the judgment below, and did not permit further proceedings in the inferior court, if the defendants' consented to the modification directed as to the amount of damages. This consent has been given, as the record shows; and the judgment of the court below is the judgment which the Supreme Court directed that court to enter and carry into execution. The litigation was ended by the decision of the Supreme Court. No discretion was left in the court below if the required consent was given.

The writ of error was properly directed to the Supreme Court of thfe State. We can only re-examine the “final judgment or decree in any suit in the highest court of a State in which a decision in the suit could be had.” Rev. Stat. sect. 709. For the purposes of such a re-examination, we require the record upon' which the judgment or decree was given, and we send out our writ of error to bring it here. That writ is to operate on the court having the record, and not upon the parties.

Cohens

v. Virginia, 6 Wheat. 410. The citation goes to the parties, and brings them before us. The writ of error, therefore, is properly “ directed to the court which holds. the proceedings as part of its own records, and exercises judicial power over them.”

Hunt

v. Palas, 4 How. 590.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.