Supreme Court of New Hampshire August 11, 1876 (Tyler v. Flanders)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-08-1876

lead-opinion

FROM COOS CIRCUIT COURT. In this case, at the first trial, there was a verdict for the defendants on the first count, and the jury did not agree on the second. The only exceptions, therefore, are those made by the plaintiff to the matters in evidence relating to the first count. The gist of this count was the malicious over-valuation of the property. It was necessary to show that it was over-valued, and that the over-valuation was malicious. To rebut any evidence of malice, it was competent for the defendants to show by the defendant Young the circumstances under which the valuation was raised, what took place at the time, and the circumstances attending it. The exception to this evidence must be overruled. The evidence offered tending to show an over-valuation of the horse was properly rejected, because such over-valuation was not complained of. *Page 624 The first request to charge the jury was rightly refused. The evidence as reported does not tend to show that a single selectman undertook to appraise the property. Flanders undertook to do just what, in Gordon v. Norris, 29 N.H. 198, it is said that one selectman may do, viz., to make an application for an account of taxable property. As to the second request, it does not appear to me, from the evidence reported, that these was anything for it to apply to. I do not understand, from the evidence reported, that there was any question as to any neglect or refusal to give an account, or any wilful omission of any property; but the question appears to have been about the appraisal of it, which, as I understand the statute, is for the selectmen to do after the list has been given them. I do not understand that any part of the charge was excepted to, I or do I see anything exceptionable. The two counts in the declaration were in fact entirely distinct.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.