Supreme Court of Alabama December 15, 1876 (Sledge v. Scott)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1876
BBICKELL, C. J.
The law, as settled in this State, is, that a misrepresentation by a vendor of chattels, of a material fact, made at the time of, or pending the negotiation for the sale, on which the purchaser has the right to rely, and in fact relies, is a fraud, furnishing a cause of action to the purchaser, or a ground of defense to an action for the purchase-money. If the representation is not a mere expression *206of opinion, but the affirmation of a fact, it is not material whether the vendor knew, or had means of knowing it to be untrue, or that he made it in ignorance of the fact. The affirmation of that which he does not know to be true, produces the same injury, and is as indefensible, in contemplation of law, as the assertion of v/hat he knows to be false.— Atwood v. Wright, 29 Ala. 346; Blackman v. Johnson, 35 Ala. 252; Munroe v. Pritchett, 16 Ala. 785; Story on Sales, § 165.
The misrepresentation must be of a material fact, on which the purchaser has a right to rely. It must not be in respect to a mere matter of opinion, or belief, or a matter apparent to the observation of the purchaser, if he exercised ordinary prudence. — Story on Sales, § 169. It must have exercised an influence on the decision to purchase. If the purchaser decides on his own judgment of the quality of the chattel, after an examination of it, or on the judgment of others who may have examined it for him, he is not deceived by the representation, and has no legal cause to complain of it. Fraud and damage must concur: fraud without damage, or damage without fraud, is not a cause of action, or a ground of defense. The deceit practiced on him, inducing a purchase he would not have made, is the true legal ground of complaint. We do not understand that the purchaser must have trusted wholly to the representation — that it must have been the exclusive inducement or consideration of the purchase.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit