Supreme Court of Arkansas November 15, 1876 (McDearman v. McClure)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1876

English, Ch. J. :

This suit was commenced on the law side of the Independence •Circuit Court, by Moses McClure against ¥m. W. McDearman, in April, 1869, and, after demurrer interposed to the complaint, was, upon the application of the plaintiff, transferred to the equity docket, and the complaint amended so as to make it a bill by one tenant in common against his co-tenant for partition of a sawmill and lot of leased ground on which it stood,' and for contribution for repairs, etc.

During the progress of the cause, McDearman sold his undivided third of -the property in dispute to McClure, and, by agreement of parties, the litigation was continued as to the claim of McClure for repairs. McClure claimed that he had made repairs upon the mill of the value of $634.75, and sought to charge McDearman with one-third of that sum.

Upon the pleadings and voluminous depositions the court, upon the final hearing, found that McClure, who owned two-thirds of the mill and ground lease, had done repairs upon the mill, etc., necessary to preserve it from waste and destruction, of the value of $336.50, and rendered a decree against McDearman for $112.16, being one-third of that amount.

During the progress of the suit, McDearman, by an amendment to his answer, set up a cross claim for the rent of the mill, which the court did not allow upon the hearing.

He appealed from the final decree to this court.

First — As to the claim for repairs:

The mill was at Ramsey’s Ferry, on White River, near Bates-ville.

On, and for some time before the 3d of August, 3867, appellant owned an undivided third of-the mill and ground lease, and ¥m. "W. Ingrum owned the other two-thirds. On that day, by written contract, appellant leased to Ingrum, for twelve months from the 1st of August, 1867, his undivided third of the saw-mill, fixtures, privileges and ground lease, to be returned to him at the end of the year, “ with the entire property in all respects in.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.