Illinois Supreme Court June 15, 1876 (O'Brian v. Fry)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1876
Mr. Justice Dickey
delivered the opinion of the Court:
It is insisted that the findings of the court are not supported by the proofs, and, in that connection, it is suggested that the testimony of one witness can not avail against the sworn answers of two defendants, equal (as suggested) to the direct testimony of four witnesses. This position can not be sustained. In so far as matter in a sworn answer is responsive to the bill, it must be held to be true, unless contradicted by two witnesses; but in so far as matter stated in an answer is new matter—about which the bill does not call for any answer, matter set np (not in denial of any allegation of the bill) as matter of defense—the answer is not evidence at all.
In this case, the complainant alleged the making of the notes and mortgage, and the failure to pay, and called on defendants to confess these allegations. The defendants admit these allegations to be true, but affirmatively allege other matter, showing that these notes ought not to be paid. As to this other matter, the sworn answers are not competent as proofs, and the burden of proof as to them rests on the defendants. Mo proof was offered in support of these allegations, and hence the finding of the Court on this record was right. It was, however, error to decree that the immediate possession of the mortgaged premises should he surrendered, in a case like this, to the complainant, before a master’s sale fully consummated, by a master’s deed, after the lapse of the statutory time for redemption. Aldrich v. Sharp, 3 Scam. 261; Bennett et al. v. Matson, 41 Ill. 343.
Although the mortgagee is entitled to possession, under his mortgage, after condition broken, still it would be a vicious practice to permit a decree for a sale of the mortgaged premises to provide for putting complainant in possession between the date of the decree and the day of sale.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit