Tennessee Supreme Court December 15, 1876 (Organ v. Allison)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1876

Deaderick, C. J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

This case is brought from the Circuit Court of Smith county by writ of error. It is an action brought on a note under seal — one Moores being principal, and defendant Allison and others sureties.

More than half the record consists in pleas, replications, demurrers and motions to strike out, etc. But the material and controlling question arose on the following facts, under the pleas of non est factum.

In 1856, Moores borrowed $1,000 of plaintiff’s intestate and executed his note under seal, and Allison also signed the note with his seal, as a surety; other sureties also signed the note with their seals, and lastly it was signed by N. Ward, one of the partners, by his firm name of N. & S. Ward, with a seal annexed to the signature of the firm, and was then delivered by Moores to the intestate, and the $1,000 paid over to him.

When the note was delivered to Gordon, the intestate, it had no blot on, or erasure of the “ seal,” to the firm name of N. & S. Ward; but when the •suit was brought, in 1867, there was an oblong blot *461on, or obliteration of the word “ seal,” made by ink of a different color from that in which the note, signatures and seals thereto were originally written. There is no direct evidence showing when, how or by whom the word seal was effaced.

Bowen, the son-in-law of Gordon, who was examined as a witness by defendant, stated that when Moores delivered the note to Gordon, the latter remarked that he thought Nathan Ward knew better than to sign the firm name to a seal,” etc.

The defendants offered to prove by witnesses how the obliteration seemed to have been made, whether by accident or design, but plaintiff objected, and the court sustained the objection and the evidence was excluded.

The plaintiff excepts to the charge of the court, in its instructions upon the question of the alleged alteration of the instrument sued on.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.