Supreme Court of New Jersey November 15, 1876 (Quick v. Corlies)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1876

*12The opinion of the court was delivered by

Scudder, J.

This obligation being under seal, the action upon it must be commenced within sixteen years next after the cause of action shall have accrued, and not after, by the statute of limitations of our state. As it was payable one day after date, the time expired in 1870, and the action was not brought until 1875. The suit is, therefore, barred by the statute, unless it be saved by the clause that the claim “ is not to- outlaw by the statute of limitations.”

It is said that' this clause is of no legal effect, because' it avoids the express terms of a statute by private agreement, and is against the policy of the law.

The general rule is, that no contract or agreement can modify a law, but the exception, is, that where no principle of public policy is violated, parties are at liberty to forego the protection of the law. Statutory provisions designed for the benefit of individuals, may be waived, but where the enactment is to secure general objects of policy or morals, no consent will render a non-compliance with the statute effectual. Sedg. on Stab, and Const. Law 109-421. This statute, limiting a time within which action shall be brought, is for the benefit and repose of individuals and not to secure general objects of policy or morals. Its protection may, therefore, be waived- by those who assent in legal form, and when acted upon, such waiver becomes an estoppel to plead the statute. Thus it is said in Cowart v. Perrine, 6 C. E. Green 101, that a defendant who has agreed not to set up the statute of limitations, shall not be allowed to do it; that such agreement, although if does not amount to a new promise, will operate by way of estoppel, in cases where the statute has not fully run, and the plaintiff forebore to sue in consequence of the promise. This rule is not confined to courts of equity, which •follow courts of law in giving effect to this statute.

In Gaylord v. Van Loan, 15 Wend. 308, and Bloodgood v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.