The Superior Court of New York City August 1, 1876 (Cochran v. Gottwald)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-08-1876
By the Court. —Curtis, J.
This case presents different questions from those appearing upon the former appeal (40 N. Y. Superior Ct. 442). The pleadings have been since substantially amended.
The property had been delivered to the plaintiff, and the defendant in his answer claimed a return of it. It is the right of the plaintiff, when in such a case the verdict is for the defendant, to return the property, instead of paying the value of it. Such payment can only be required of him where a return cannot be had (Code, § 261, subd. 1).
The Code, § 277, directs that “if the property has been delivered to the plaintiff, and the defendant claim a return thereof, judgment for the defendant may be for a return of the property, or the value thereof, in case a return cannot be had.”
These two sections of the Code indicate the form of the verdict and of the judgment to be entered upon it, in a case like the present, when the property in question has been delivered to the plaintiff, and the defendants by their answer claim a return of it.
It is difficult to reconcile with these specific provisions, the verdict of the jury and the judgment entered in the present case.
The judgment as to the horses is not in the alternative, as it should have been.
It is not sufficient to say, that the plaintiff could not return them as there had been testimony tending to show he had sold them. What disposition he had made with the horses in the mean time, does not affect his legal right to return them, instead of paying for them. This right the law unrestrictedly secures to him, provided he is able to do so, when judgment is entered against him. The plaintiff objects to the pro*322vision in the judgment that the defendant recover one hundred and seventy-seven dollars and seventy-seven cents, costs and disbursements taxed on the former trial. The present record justifies no such provision in the judgment entered upon this verdict.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit