Supreme Court of Virginia September 25, 1877 (Snavely v. Harkrader)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-09-1877
Christian, J.,
delivered the opinion of the court.
The first question we have to determine in tins case arises upon a demurrer filed by the defendant Snavely, both to the original and amended bills.
The ground of demurrer asserted is, that the original bill was multifarious, and that the same objection applies to the amended bill. If the demurrer be sustained as to either it must be sustained as to both.
The bill was filed by the children of Jas. H. Harkrader, all of whom were infants, (except one, who was of age, Frances C. Harkrader, but she being non compos mentis,) by their next friend, against the appellant Snavely, as guardian of the infants and committee of said Frances. The object of the bill seems to be two-fold: First, to surcharge and falsify the ex parte account of the guardian already settled, and for cause alleged in the bill to have him removed from his guardianship; and, second, to have a sale made of the wards’ real estate. It is insisted that the bill thus seeking two distinct and independent objects, wholly disconnected with each other, is multifarious. According to Lord Cottenham (and in this he has been followed by courts and text-writers), it is utterly impossible, upon the authorities, to lay down any rule or abstract proposition as to what constitutes multifariousness, which can be made universally applicable. The cases upon the subject are extremely various, and the courts in deciding them seem to have considered what was convenient in particular cases rather than to have attempted to lay down an absolute rule. The only way of reconciling the authorities on the subject, is by adverting to the fact that although the books speak generally of demurrers for multifariousness, yet in truth such *126demuiTers may be divided in two distinct kinds.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit