Illinois Supreme Court September 15, 1877 (Dunham v. South Park Commissioners)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1877

Mr. Justice Breese

delivered the opinion of the Court:

This is a writ of error to the circuit court of Cook county, to bring up the record and proceedings of that court, had at the July terin, 1877, in a case in which the South Park Commissioners were plaintiffs, and John H. Dunham and others defendants, and in which there was an amendment of the record of a prior term of that court, and to which Dunham excepted.

It appears that at the June term of that court, held in 1872, the South Park Commissioners had applied to that court for a confirmation of a special assessment made on the real estate of Dunham and others, for the purposes of the South Park, which was granted by the court.

In May, 1877, Dunham sued out a writ of error, which was made a supersedeas, to reverse this judgment, the error relied on being that the record of those proceedings showed that all five of the judges of the Cook circuit court sat in the proceedings and participated in the judgment and orders entered therein.

The cause being thus pending in this court, in July thereafter the South Park Commissioners, then defendants in the writ of error, gave notice to the attorneys of Dunham, the plaintiff in error, that they would make application to the circuit court to correct the record, so as to conform to the truth, namely: that said term of the circuit court was held and presided over by Erastus S. Williams alone, who was one of the judges of that circuit, and the proceedings had before him alone.

Dunham appeared to the motion, and such proceedings were had as to result in an amendment erasing the recital of the presence of five judges, as in the original record. On a suggestion of diminution of the record, this court allowed a certiorari to the circuit court, and this corrected and amended record is the return thereto, and they insist that the amendment so allowed obviates the objection made to the original-record.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.