Supreme Court of Iowa December 10, 1877 (State v. Quinn)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-12-1877
Seevers, J.
i. criminal ling.' swm ~ The indictment charged that on the 25th day af August, 1876, the defendant, “by means of a certain device and game did obtain from Richard 0. Oppies the sum of five dollars, lawful money; said device being a sleight of hand game, performed with a strap, and known ■as the strap game.” To this indictment there was a demurrer, on the ground no crime was charged therein. The demurrer *369was overruled. ■ -The statute provides, “ That whoever by the means of three-card monte, so called, or any other form or device, sleight of hand, or other means, whatever, by use of cards or other instruments of like character, obtains from' another person any money or other property * * * shall be deemed guilty of swindling.”
It is argued that the alleged criminal act must be both within the letter and spirit of the statute before a conviction can be sustained. This is undoubtedly true, and another proposition advanced by counsel is equally true, and that is that in the construction of penal statutes, where there is doubt and uncertainty whether the alleged criminal act comes within the scope of the statute, such a construction should be adopted as to exclude it. It is elementary in the construction of criminal statutes that alleged criminal acts, unless plainly within the letter, spirit and reason of the statute, should not by a forced or unnatural construction be brought within its terms. Keeping these well known principles in view, and giving them due weight and importance in the construction of this statute, we arrive at the conclusion that a person may be guilty of swindling under' this statute: 1. Of obtaining money or property by means of three card monte, so called; 2. Or by any other form or device; 3. Or by any sleight of hand performance; 4. By means of cards or instruments of like character. We are unable to conclude the letter or intent of the statute requires the construction that the crime cam only be committed by the use of cards.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit