New York Court of Appeals February 19, 1878 (Wilkinson v. First National Fire Insurance Co. of Worcester)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-02-1878

Andrews, J.

The policies were issued to Martin Wallace, one of the firm of James Thompson & Co., to which firm the loss, if any, was payable. The plaintiff derives title to the claim against the defendant by virtue of an assignment from Thompson

& Co.,

made June 11, 1873. The fire which destroyed the insured property occurred January 14, 1871. The proofs of loss were served immediately thereafter, and this action was commenced October 16, 1873—nearly two years and nine months after the fire. The policies contain a provision that no suit for the recovery of any claim thereunder shall be sustainable in any court of law or chancery, unless it shall be commenced within twelve months after the loss or damage shall occur, any statute of limitation to the contrary notwithstanding. It is well-settled that the parties to a contract may provide

*502

for a shorter limitation to actions thereon than that fixed by •the general law. Such an agreement is. not expressly or impliedly prohibited by the general statute of limitations, and is consistent with the policy upon which statutes of limitation are founded. (Ames v.

The New York Union Ins. Co.,

14 N. Y., 253;

Ripley

v.

Ætna Ins. Co.,

30 id., 136;

Roach

v.

N. Y. & E. Ins. Co.,

id. 546;

Mayor

v.

Hamilton Ins. Co.,

39 id., 46.) The defendant, among other defenses, set up the contract limitation in bar of the action. The plaintiff, to avoid this defense, proved the following facts: In April, 1871, an action was commenced in the Supreme Court, in which the Cambridge Valley National Bank was plaintiff, and Wallace, Thompson

&

Co. and The First National Fire Insurance Company of Worcester were defendants, in which the bank claimed by virtue of an alleged agreement with Wallace, to be entitled to the policies of insurance now sued upon, and to the money due thereon, and prayed for an injunction restraining the insurance company from paying, and Wallace, Thompson & Co.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.