Supreme Court of Pennsylvania February 4, 1878 (Freeman v. Shreve)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-02-1878
Mr. Justice Sharswood
delivered the opinion of the court,
It is undisputed and indisputable from the testimony of the plaintiff below himself that he was retained by Mr. Freeman, on behalf of his wife, “to secure the safe custody of the estate of Isaac Brown Parker and his wife’s interest, and take it out of the hands of John Brown Parker. He (Mr. Freeman) said, ‘ If you will do that we will give you $5000.’ ” This, then, was the contract on the plaintiff’s own showing. All the services which he could or did render to the estate were clearly within the scope of his duty under this undertaking. Had he failed in taking any steps which were necessary to secure the general fund, he would *138have been derelict in his duty, and responsible to Mrs. Freeman and nobody else for any loss which she might sustain t>y his neglect. He would not have been responsible to the other claimants upon the fund, for he owed them no duty. He could in no event have called upon them for compensation, though in attending to and protecting the interest of Mrs. Freeman he was at the same time attending to and protecting theirs. All that he did in the cause was under and by virtue of his retainer as solicitor of Mrs. Freeman. It does not appear that he was retained or acted as solicitor for any other party to the cause. His services then were rendered under his contract to secure the safe custody of the estate and Mrs. Freeman’s interest. No part of the $2500 which he received by the order of the chancellor, was for services rendered to anybody else but Mrs. Freeman. She was the owner of the seventh of the general fund, and to protect her seventh as long as it was undivided it was necessary to protect that general fund.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit