Illinois Supreme Court September 15, 1878 (Campbell v. Day)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1878

Mr. Justice Scholfield

delivered the opinion of the Court:

In September, 1872, appellees, as administrators of the estate of Isaac C. Day, deceased, entered into a contract with T. J. Darcy, whereby the latter undertook to furnish materials for erecting and finishing a certain building in the city of Chicago, for the sum of $59,000.

By the terms of the contract the building was to be completed in a good and workmanlike manner, according to the plans and specifications prepared by W. L. B. Jenny, architect, in the following month of December. The compensation was to be paid from time to time, as the work progressed, upon the architect’s certificates, reserving a percentage until the whole work should be finished, the owners being at liberty to make changes and alterations without prejudice to the contract, and not to be answerable for any loss or damage that might happen to the work. Subsequent to the making of this contract, Darcy entered into a contract with Burkhardt & Sherwin, whereby the latter undertook to do all the cut stone work. The plans and specifications, which were made part of the contract between appellees and Darcy, provided for brick piers in the basement of the building, upon which the superstructure was to be erected.

The building was not completed in December, as provided by contract, nor for some months thereafter. Work, however, progressed on the building during the month of December and the following winter months, and, as is said by one of the witnesses, about the time the frost was coming out, (which we presume was in the latter part of winter or early part of spring,) the brick piers gave away, threatening the safety of the superstructure. From the evidence of Mr. Jenny, the supervising architect, it appears that bad workmanship was the cause of the weakness in the piers. These brick piers were taken out, and replaced with stone piers.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.