Supreme Court of New Hampshire June 5, 1879 (Rogers v. Elliott)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-06-1879
Stanley, J.
The power to attach on
mesne
process does not exist at common law. It is given by statute, and authorizes the
*202
seizure of all property, real' and personal, which may be taken on execution. Gen. St.,
c.
205,
s.
1.
The statute specifies what, property may be so taken, but grass, ripe and fit for harvest, is not included with it. It was not, then, attachable, unless it could be taken on execution at common law. Gen. St.,
co.
217, 218, 219, 220.
At common law, all the goods and chattels of the debtor, including emblements and all present profits of the land, could be taken. ■Com. Dig., Execution,
c.
3.
Emblements were regarded as personal property, but that term •does not include fruits which grow on trees which are not planted yearly, grass, and the like. It only includes those crops which grow yearly, and are raised annually by expense and labor, or great manurance or industry. The fruits and products of the earth, other than emblements, while they are hanging by the roots, are a ■part of the realty. As soon as they are gathered they are personal estate. Bouv. Inst. 471, 1518; 4 Kent. Com. 73.
Things which proceed annually of themselves, without the labor of man, are not emblements, as grass, though improved by the labor of man. Com. Dig., Biens G, 1.
Grass and standing trees are part and parcel of the land in which they are rooted, and as such are real property. They pass to the heir as part of the inheritance, and not to the executor or administrator, and they cannot be sold on an execution against chattels only. 3 Kent. Com. 401; 4 Kent. Com. 73;
Green
v. Armstrong, 1 Den. 550, 554, 556;
Cudworth
v. Scott, 41 N. H. 456, 462, 463;
Penhallow
v. Dwight, 7 Mass. 34;
Miller
v. Baker, 1 Met. 27. The grass in question was part of the realty. It was not liable to be attached as personal property, and the defendants’ justification fails.
The defendants rely on
Norris
v.
Watson,
22 N. H.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit