Supreme Court of North Carolina January 5, 1879 (Williamson v. . Buck)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-01-1879
Ashe, J.
This was an action of claim and delivery for a horse, instituted by the plaintiff against the defendant, brought by appeal from the June term, 1878, of superior court of-Wake county. Both parties waived a jury trial and referred all the issues of law and fact, for decision, to the court. The defendant insisted on the trial and we must consider it as a special instruction prayed for, “ that plaintiff would not be entitled to recover in this action, unless the death of the horse was caused by the defendant, Wynne, and in that event, of which there was no evidence, only for the hire of the horse during the two weeks he -lived after the sale to Wynne.”
In answer to this instruction the court held that there was sufficient evidence from which the court might find as a fact that the death of the horse was occasioned by the acts or negligence of the .defendant, Wynne, in taking and detaining it or while he was detaining it; and referred as to
*312
'his finding, upon these points to the 6th and 7th sections of •his findings of fact set out in the record. The sections referred to are as follows:
6. “ The horse having died while so detained as aforesaid ■and the defendants being wrong-doers, they ar
e prima facie
-liable to the plaintiff for its value as a loss occasioned by the taking and detention, and the burden is on them to •prove the cause of the death and to show that it was in no 'degree attributable to their negligence, nor to the fact that they had'taken and were detaining it.”
7. “ That the defendants have not shown this, on the contrary, the court finds as a fact that the death of the horse was occasioned by its removal out of the possession of the plaintiff in the country, into the possession of the defendants in town, and being kept in tpwn and by the uses to which it was put and the manner in which it was tended and managed while it was so detained by the defendant, Wynne.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit