Supreme Court of North Carolina January 5, 1879 (State v. . Matthews)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-01-1879
Dillard, J.
The prisoners were tried and convicted of manslaughter at fall term. 1878, of Surry superior court and from the judgment pronounced, an appeal is taken to this court, for alleged irregularity in 'the formation of the jury which tried them, and for error of the presiding judge in the instructions given, and in the refusal of other in.structions requested. In order to understand the matters
*419
complained of and to make the opinion of this court i’nteb ligible in relation thereto, it will be necessary to state briefly the material facts as they appear upon the record sent up to this court.
When the jury were being formed, a juror regularly drawn was challenged by the prisoners, and on being sworn to answer touching Ms competency to serve on the jury, the prisoners proposed to ask him, — whether he had formed and expressed the opinion that the prisoners at the bar or either of them was guilty of either murder or
manslaughter;
and on objection, His Honor ruled that the question should be put, have you formed and expressed the opinion that the prisoners at the bar or either of them is guilty, remarking at the time that the inquiry in that form covered both murder and manslaughter, and was in accordance with the usual practice in the courts, and to this ruling the prisoners excepted.
We think there was nothing in the ruling of His Honor of which the prisoners have just cause of complaint. It is the undoubted legal right of the parties to any action, whether civil or criminal, to have the matter in issue passed upon by a jury, competent and free from all just cause of challenge j and it is settled law that the forming and expressing of an opinion on the matter to be tried is ground of principal challenge and renders the juryman incompetent.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit