Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court May 12, 1879 (Fitch v. Taft)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-05-1879
Lobd, J.
The complainant asks to have his annual damages for the flowing of his land by the respondent’s dam reassessed by a jury, under the provisions of the Gen. Sts. o. 149, § 34. The respondent denies his right to a reassessment, upon the ground that the annual damages have been fixed by arbitration between the parties; and that the award of the arbitrators is final and conclusive, and cannot be reopened.
The complainant, on October 8, 1874, instituted an original complaint, under the Gen. Sts. c. 149, which was duly entered in court. The statute provides that in such a case the jury shall determine what amount of damages the complainant shall have sustained within three years next preceding the filing of his complaint. For such sum, the complainant is entitled to an execution. It is further provided that the jury shall also assess a sum in gross, which shall be full compensation for all damages to be sustained by maintaining the dam forever; and that the jury shall determine the amount of damages to be paid annually by the respondent for the right to maintain his dam. The complainant may within a limited time elect to take the gross sum thus assessed as full compensation for all injury to be thereafter sustained, or to take the annual damages as ascertained by the jury. By §§ 34, 36 of that chapter, if either party is dissatisfied with the annual compensation established by the jury, a new complaint may be instituted for the increase or diminution thereof, or for ascertaining the gross amount of the damages, with the limitations that the new complaint shall not be brought for the increase or diminution of the annual compensation “ until the expiration of one month after the payment of the then last year has fallen due,” nor for the assessment of gross damages, *504when the party has not elected to receive such gross damages, until the expiration of ten years thereafter.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit