Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court July 10, 1879 (Franklin Insurance v. Cousens)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-07-1879

Morton, J.

The mortgage deed under which the plaintiff claims conveys to it a lot of land one of the boundaries of which is described as on “ Cedar Square,” being the premises “ lately known as the Hotel Flanders.” Before this deed was made, *261Reed the mortgagor, being the owner of the land now claimed by the plaintiff and the defendant, had laid out and graded over the. land claimed by the defendant, on the northerly front of the plaintiff’s premises, a way thirty feet wide, running from Cedar Street to McLean Place.

This way was graded and finished, curved curbstones having been set up by the city at the corners of Cedar Street, and was intended and used by the defendant, and by the plaintiff after it took possession, as a private foot and carriage way and means of access to the Hotel Flanders.

The only question in this case is whether the plaintiff took by implication a right of way over the thirty-foot passageway; and we are of opinion that it did. The rule is, that, when a grantor conveys land bounded on a street or way over his other land, he and those claiming under him are estopped to deny the existence of such street or way. Tobey v. Taunton, 119 Mass. 404. Lewis v. Beattie, 105 Mass. 410. Howe v. Alger, 4 Allen, 206.

If the plaintiff’s northerly line had been described as bounded upon a way or passageway thirty feet wide, it is too clear to admit of discussion that the grantor and the defendant claiming under him would be estopped to deny the plaintiff’s right to a way thirty feet wide between Cedar Street and McLean Place.

It can make no difference that the way is called by another name. The question is whether the thing intended as a boundary was in fact a way ; if it was, it is immaterial whether it is called a way, or a street, avenue, lane, road, place or court.

Thus, in the case at bar, there seems to be a street called “ McLean Place,” which is a boundary of the lands of both the plaintiff and defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.