Supreme Court of Vermont August 15, 1879 (Belknap, Ely & Co. v. Paddock)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1879

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Ross, J.

On the facts shown and concessions made by the plaintiffs on the trial, the County Court ordered a verdict for the defendant. This action of the County Court was not erroneous, if the facts and concessions clearly showed that the plaintiffs were not entitled to recover in this action. The declaration counts *5upon a liability of the defendant to the plaintiffs jointly, growing out of an agreement under seal, signed by each of the plaintiffs and the defendant, with reference to the expense of the defence of certain anticipated suits against any one of the parties or his customers, by Lane, Pitkin & Brock, for an infringement of certain patent rights in the manufacture of circular saw-mills ; and avers that the defendant agreed to pay his proportion of such expenses to the defendant defending said suits. It alleges that the agreement was an indenture between the plaintiffs and the defendant. This is tantamount to an averment that the plaintiffs jointly formed one party to the indenture and the defendant the other. The agreement put in evidence by the plaintiffs is the several agreement of each of the parties thereto with every other party to the same “ to pay his equal proportion of the damages, costs and expenses of defending all suits which shall be brought and tried for the purpose of testing said right, whether brought against either or all of us, or either of our customers ; and we each agree to furnish an equal proportion of the money which may be necessary from time to time to pay the expenses of such defense, to be paid to the defendants trying said cases.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.