Wisconsin Supreme Court January 15, 1879 (Stetler v. Chicago & Northwestern Railway Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1879
Taylor, J.
The learned counsel for the appellant insists that the court below erred in holding that the defendant was liable to the plaintiff for an injury resulting from the insufficiency of the railroad track which it did not own, and was not bound to keep in repair; and seeondli/, that the court erred in refusing to instruct the jury, “ that if they found that negligence of the defendant’s employees caused the injury, or contributed to it, the defendant would not be liable,” and because, in reply to such request, the judge said he did not think there was any negligence on the part of anybody running that train, “ I mean the train hands; that the negligence, if any, was higher up; ” and thirdly, that the damages were excessive, and that the verdict should have been set aside, and a new trial granted, for that reason.
1. We do not think the first point well taken. The authorities are quite uniform, that where one railroad company uses the track of another company for the purpose of transporting passengers or piuperty, the company transporting the persons or property is liable for any damages which may be sustained, either by the passengers or by the owners of the property so transported, caused by any defects in the road of the other company so used, or by the negligence of the servants or employees of such other company occurring during such transportation. Redfield, in his work on the law of railways, says; “ The rule of law in regard to passenger-carriers who run over other *503roads than their own, seems now to be pretty well established, that the first company is responsible for the entire route, and must take the risk of the negligence of the employees of the other companies.” 2 Redfield on the Law of Railways, 303. See Railroad Co. v. Barron, 5 Wall., 90; 2 Redf. Am. Railw. Cases, 471; Ill. Central Railroad v. Kanouse, 30 Ill., 272; McElroy and wife v. Railroad Corp., 4 Cush., 400.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit