Illinois Supreme Court September 15, 1879 (Diversey v. Johnson)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1879

Mr. Justice Baker

delivered the opinion of the Court:

It is urged the fundamental error herein, upon the part of the Superior Court, was in attempting to make a decree in the condition of affairs disclosed by the proofs. It is true, the lapse of time, the death of the parties and of many of the witnesses, the destruction of the files, records and testimony in the original suit, and of the books and papers of the firms of Johnson & Diversey, and Lili & Diversey, have rendered it difficult, if not impossible, to ascertain with precision the exact state of accounts between the former partners. The point is made, in such cases courts of equity decline to interfere, and 1 Story’s Eq. Jur. §529, and other authorities, are cited in that behalf. The exception to the rule relied on is found in the latter part of the section referred to; it is, that “under peculiar circumstances, excusing or justifying the delay, courts of equity will not refuse their aid in furtherance of the rights of the party, since, in such cases, there is no pretence to insist upon laches or negligence as a ground for dismissal of the suit.” The cases cited by appellant are all cases where relief was refused on account of laches imputed to complainant.

But this is all res adjudicata, so far as regards this controversy. When the case was here before (Johnson, Admx. v. Diversey et al. 82 Ill. 446) we said : “All the facts and circumstances considered, it does not appear complainant has been guilty of such laches as would deprive her of any standing in a court of equity.” And also said: “The difficulties in the way of taking an accurate account, in consequence of the death of the parties and of some important witnesses, Ave apprehend will be quite as embarrassing to complainant as to defendants. But were it otherwise, that fact constitutes no insuperable objection to adjusting accounts of trust funds that ought to ha\m beén done sooner.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.