U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Virginia January 30, 1879 (Lee v. Kaufman)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-01-1879
HUGHES, District Judge.
The two instructions3 a asked for by the plaintiff, and the instructions No. 1 asked for by the defendants, depend upon the same principles of law, and may be' considered together. I think these instructions embrace the principles of law which control the case under trial, and it would seem to ■. be hardly necessary to give much special consideration to the other instructions offered. I will premise that the certificate of the sale of Arlington made by the tax commissioners, which can be impeached only by showing either, 1st, that the property was not subject to the tax for which it was sold; or 2d, that it was after the sale redeemed from the tax according to the provisions of the law of 1862; or 3d, that the tax had been paid before the tax sale; is impeached by the plaintiff in this suit only on the last of these grounds. The sale is conceded to have been valid in other respects. This objection to the sale is made by the plaintiff not on the claim that the tax was in fact paid, but on the claim that he (or his predecessor in title) did all that he was bound to do by law towards paying it; that the non-receipt of it by the government was- not through fault of his, but through fault of its own officers; and that, having himself done what was the equivalent of paying the tax, the land was not forfeited by law, and the commissioners’ sale of the property for the tax was therefore unauthorized, null, and void.
The instructions under consideration all relate to the question whether the acts of the plaintiff (or of his predecessor) in regard to the payment of the tax were in law the equivalent of payment to the extent of preventing a forfeiture.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit